.. _data-label: Plots and Data ======================================================== We provide data with a consistent choice of units in order to compare in the plots below. Our choice of units: - The **first** column of each :data:`.csv` text file is given as :math:`\log_{10}(m_N/\mathrm{GeV})` - The **second** column of each :data:`.csv` text file is given as :math:`\log_{10}(|U_{\alpha N}|^2)` We also give the :data:`.png`, :data:`.pdf` and :data:`.py` plotting code for the figures below. A :data:`.bib` file containing the references below: :download:`References `. Updates ----------------------------------- - 31/03/2023: Added BEBC limits on :math:`|U_{eN}|^2` and :math:`|U_{\tau N}|^2` from Ref. :cite:`Barouki:2022bkt`. Electron Mixing :math:`|U_{eN}|^2` ----------------------------------- Current Constraints ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ .. _econstraintscurrent: .. figure:: plots/UeNsq_constraints.png :align: right :figwidth: 700px Current constraints on the electron neutrino-sterile neutrino mixing :math:`|U_{eN}|^2` as a function of the sterile neutrino mass :math:`m_N`. - :download:`All Data ` - :download:`PDF File `/:download:`PNG File ` - :download:`Plotting Code ` +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Experiment/Analysis | Reference | Data | +===============================================================================+==============================================================================+===========================================================================================================================================================================+ | Daya Bay | :cite:`An:2016luf` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | DANSS | :cite:`Alekseev:2018efk` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | KamLAND | :cite:`Cirelli:2004cz` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Solar and KamLAND | :cite:`Dentler:2018sju` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | NEOS | :cite:`Ko:2016owz` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | SuperKamiokande + IceCube + DeepCore | :cite:`Dentler:2018sju` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | :math:`^3\mathrm{H}` Beta Decay (Hiddemann et al.) | :cite:`Hiddemann:1995ce` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | :math:`^3\mathrm{H}` Beta Decay (Mainz) | :cite:`Kraus:2012he` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | :math:`^3\mathrm{H}` Beta Decay (Troitsk 2013) | :cite:`Belesev:2013cba` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | :math:`^3\mathrm{H}` Beta Decay (Troitsk 2017) | :cite:`Abdurashitov:2017kka` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | :math:`^{137}\mathrm{Re}` Beta Decay | :cite:`PhysRevLett.86.1978` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | :math:`^{63}\mathrm{Ni}` Beta Decay | :cite:`Holzschuh:1999vy` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | :math:`^{35}\mathrm{S}` Beta Decay | :cite:`Holzschuh:2000nj` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | :math:`^{45}\mathrm{Ca}` Beta Decay | :cite:`Derbin:1997ut` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | :math:`^{64}\mathrm{Cu}` Beta Decay | :cite:`Schreckenbach:1983cg` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | :math:`^{144}\mathrm{Ce}-^{144}\mathrm{Pr}` Beta Decay | :cite:`Derbin2018` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | :math:`^{20}\mathrm{F}` Beta Decay | :cite:`PhysRevC.27.1175` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | BeEST :math:`^{7}\mathrm{Be}` Beta Decay | :cite:`Friedrich:2020nze` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Rovno | :cite:`Derbin:1993wy` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Bugey | :cite:`PhysRevD.52.1343` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Borexino | :cite:`PhysRevD.88.072010` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | PIENU | :cite:`Aguilar-Arevalo:2017vlf` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Improved Pion Decay Contraints | :cite:`Bryman:2019ssi,Bryman:2019bjg` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | PS191 (+ Reanalysis) | :cite:`Bernardi:1987ek` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | IHEP-JINR | :cite:`Baranov:1992vq,Aguilar-Arevalo:2017vlf` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | NA62 | :cite:`NA62:2020mcv` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | T2K | :cite:`Abe:2019kgx` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | SuperKamiokande | :cite:`Abe:2014gda` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | LNV Meson Decays | :cite:`Kovalenko:2009td,Atre:2009rg,Helo:2010cw,Abada:2017jjx` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CHARM | :cite:`Bergsma:1985is,Vilain:1994vg` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | BEBC | :cite:`Barouki:2022bkt` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | BESIII | :cite:`Ablikim:2019gvd` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | NA3 | :cite:`Badier:1986xz` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Belle | :cite:`Liventsev:2013zz` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | DELPHI | :cite:`Abreu:1996pa` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | L3 | :cite:`Adriani:1992pq,Achard:2001qv` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | ATLAS Dilepton + Jets | :cite:`Aad:2015xaa` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | ATLAS Trilepton Prompt LNC (LNV) | :cite:`Aad:2019kiz` | :download:`.csv ` (:download:`.csv `) | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CMS Dilepton + Jets | :cite:`Sirunyan:2018xiv` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CMS Trilepton Prompt LNC (LNV) | :cite:`Sirunyan:2018mtv` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Higgs Decays | :cite:`Das:2017zjc` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Electroweak Precision Data | :cite:`Blennow:2016jkn,deBlas:2013gla,delAguila:2008pw,Antusch:2014woa` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CMB :math:`\Delta N_{\mathrm{eff}}` | :cite:`Bridle:2016isd,Vincent:2014rja` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CMB + BAO + :math:`H_0` (or :math:`H_0` Only) | :cite:`Vincent:2014rja` | :download:`.csv ` (:download:`.csv `) | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Sterile Decays before BBN | :cite:`Boyarsky:2009ix,Ruchayskiy:2012si` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | NuSTAR X-rays | :cite:`Ng:2019gch,Roach:2019ctw` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Supernovae MSW Effect (Shi and Sigl) | :cite:`Shi:1993ee` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Supernovae MSW Effect (Raffelt and Zhou) | :cite:`Raffelt:2011nc,Zhou:2015jha` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Supernovae MSW Effect (Zhou) Lower (Upper) Limit | :cite:`Zhou:2015jha` | :download:`.csv ` (:download:`.csv `) | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | `r`-process Nucleosynthesis (Nunokawa et al.) | :cite:`Nunokawa:1997ct` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ Future Sensitivities ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ .. _econstraintsfuture: .. figure:: plots/UeNsq_future.png :align: right :figwidth: 700px Future constraints on the electron neutrino-sterile neutrino mixing :math:`|U_{eN}|^2` as a function of the sterile neutrino mass :math:`m_N`. - :download:`All Data ` - :download:`PDF File `/:download:`PNG File ` - :download:`Plotting Code ` +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Experiment/Analysis | Reference | Data | +===============================================================================+========================================================+=====================================================================================================================================================================================================+ | Current LNC Constraints (Blue Shaded) | :cite:`Bolton:2019pcu` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Current LNV Constraints (Red Shaded) | :cite:`Bolton:2019pcu` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | KATRIN :math:`^3\mathrm{H}` :math:`\beta` decay | :cite:`Mertens:2018vuu` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | TRISTAN :math:`^3\mathrm{H}` :math:`\beta` decay | :cite:`Mertens:2018vuu` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | HUNTER | :cite:`Martoff:2021vxp` | :download:`.csv `, :download:`.csv `, :download:`.csv `| +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | BeEST :math:`^{7}\mathrm{Be}` Beta Decay | :cite:`Friedrich:2020nze` | :download:`.csv `, :download:`.csv `, :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | PIONEER | :cite:`PIONEER:2022yag` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | DUNE | :cite:`Krasnov:2019kdc,Ballett:2019bgd` | :download:`.csv ` (:download:`.csv `) | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | DUNE Indirect | :cite:`Carbajal:2022zlp` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | NA62 | :cite:`Drewes:2018gkc` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | AL3X | :cite:`Dercks:2018wum` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | FASER-2 | :cite:`Feng:2017uoz` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | SHiP | :cite:`SHiP:2018xqw` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | MATHUSLA | :cite:`Chou:2016lxi` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CODEX-b | :cite:`Aielli:2019ivi` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | ANUBIS | :cite:`Hirsch:2020klk` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Future LNV Meson Decays | :cite:`Chun:2019nwi` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | LHCb Displaced Vertex | :cite:`Antusch:2017hhu,Drewes:2019fou` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | ATLAS Displaced Vertex | :cite:`Drewes:2019fou` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CMS Displaced Vertex | :cite:`Drewes:2019fou` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Lepton Displaced Vertex | :cite:`Liu:2019ayx` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | FCC-ee | :cite:`Blondel:2014bra,Alimena:2022hfr` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | ILC | :cite:`Hernandez:2018cgc` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CLIC | :cite:`Chakraborty:2018khw,Das:2018usr` | :download:`.csv ` (:download:`.csv `) | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | LHeC | :cite:`Mondal:2016kof,Das:2018usr,Antusch:2019eiz` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | High Luminosity LHC (and FCC-hh) | :cite:`Pascoli:2018heg` | :download:`.csv ` (:download:`.csv `) | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | FCC-he | :cite:`Benedikt:2018csr,Pascoli:2018heg` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | ATHENA X-rays | :cite:`Neronov:2015kca` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | eROSITA X-rays | :cite:`Dekker:2021bos` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ Muon Mixing :math:`|U_{\mu N}|^2` ---------------------------------- Current Constraints ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ .. figure:: plots/UmuNsq_constraints.png :align: right :figwidth: 700px Current constraints on the muon neutrino-sterile neutrino mixing :math:`|U_{\mu N}|^2` as a function of the sterile neutrino mass :math:`m_N`. - :download:`All Data ` - :download:`PDF File `/:download:`PNG File ` - :download:`Plotting Code ` +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Experiment/Analysis | Reference | Data | +===============================================================================+=========================================================================+===========================================================================================================================================================================+ | IceCUBE | :cite:`An:2016luf` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | MiniBooNE | :cite:`Alekseev:2018efk` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CDHS | :cite:`Dydak:1983zq` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | IceCUBE + DeepCore | :cite:`Dentler:2018sju` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | NOvA | :cite:`Dentler:2018sju` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | SuperKamiokande (Oscillations) | :cite:`Coloma:2019htx` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | MINOS(+) | :cite:`Adamson:2017uda` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CCFR | :cite:`Adamson:2017uda` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | PSI | :cite:`Daum:1987bg` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | :math:`\mu` Spectrum | :cite:`Shrock:1981wq` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | PIENU | :cite:`Aguilar-Arevalo:2019owf` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | KEK | :cite:`Hayano:1982wu,Yamazaki:1984sj` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | PS191 | :cite:`Bernardi:1987ek` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | SuperKamiokande (Decay) | :cite:`Abe:2014gda` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | E949 | :cite:`Artamonov:2014urb` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | T2K | :cite:`Abe:2019kgx` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | NA62 | :cite:`NA62:2020mcv` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | MicroBooNE | :cite:`Abratenko:2019kez,Kelly:2021xbv` | :download:`.csv `, :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | LNV Meson Decays | :cite:`Atre:2009rg,Helo:2010cw,Kovalenko:2009td,Abada:2017jjx` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | NuTeV | :cite:`Vaitaitis:1999wq` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | BEBC | :cite:`CooperSarkar:1985nh` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | FMMF | :cite:`Gallas:1994xp` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | NA3 | :cite:`Badier:1986xz` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CHARM | :cite:`Vilain:1994vg` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | LHCb | :cite:`Aaij:2014aba` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Belle | :cite:`Liventsev:2013zz` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | L3 | :cite:`Adriani:1992pq` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | DELPHI | :cite:`Abreu:1996pa` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | ATLAS | :cite:`Aad:2019kiz` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CMS | :cite:`Sirunyan:2018mtv` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Higgs Decays | :cite:`Das:2017zjc` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Electroweak Precision Data | :cite:`Blennow:2016jkn,deBlas:2013gla,delAguila:2008pw,Antusch:2014woa` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CMB :math:`\Delta N_{\mathrm{eff}}` | :cite:`Bridle:2016isd,Vincent:2014rja` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CMB + BAO + :math:`H_0` (or :math:`H_0` Only) | :cite:`Vincent:2014rja` | :download:`.csv ` (:download:`.csv `) | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Sterile Decays before BBN | :cite:`Boyarsky:2009ix,Ruchayskiy:2012si` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | NuSTAR X-rays | :cite:`Ng:2019gch,Roach:2019ctw` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Supernovae MSW Effect (Kopp) | :cite:`Arguelles:2016uwb` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ Future Sensitivities ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ .. figure:: plots/UmuNsq_future.png :align: right :figwidth: 700px Future constraints on the muon neutrino-sterile neutrino mixing :math:`|U_{\mu N}|^2` as a function of the sterile neutrino mass :math:`m_N`. - :download:`All Data ` - :download:`PDF File `/:download:`PNG File ` - :download:`Plotting Code ` +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Experiment/Analysis | Reference | Data | +===============================================================================+========================================================+======================================================================================================================================================================================+ | Current LNC Constraints (Blue Shaded) | :cite:`Bolton:2019pcu` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Current LNV Constraints (Red Shaded) | :cite:`Bolton:2019pcu` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | DUNE | :cite:`Krasnov:2019kdc,Ballett:2019bgd` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | DUNE Indirect | :cite:`Carbajal:2022zlp` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | NA62 | :cite:`Drewes:2018gkc` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | AL3X | :cite:`Dercks:2018wum` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | FASER-2 | :cite:`Feng:2017uoz` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | SHiP | :cite:`SHiP:2018xqw` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | MATHUSLA | :cite:`Chou:2016lxi` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CODEX-b | :cite:`Aielli:2019ivi` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | ANUBIS | :cite:`Hirsch:2020klk` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Future LNV Meson Decays | :cite:`Chun:2019nwi` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | LHCb Displaced Vertex | :cite:`Antusch:2017hhu,Drewes:2019fou` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | ATLAS Displaced Vertex | :cite:`Drewes:2019fou` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CMS Displaced Vertex | :cite:`Drewes:2019fou` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | FCC-ee | :cite:`Blondel:2014bra,Alimena:2022hfr` | :download:`.csv `, :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | High Luminosity LHC (and FCC-hh) | :cite:`Pascoli:2018heg` | :download:`.csv ` (:download:`.csv `) | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | ATHENA X-rays | :cite:`Neronov:2015kca` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | eROSITA X-rays | :cite:`Dekker:2021bos` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ Tau Mixing :math:`|U_{\tau N}|^2` ----------------------------------- Current Constraints ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ .. figure:: plots/UtauNsq_constraints.png :align: right :figwidth: 700px Current constraints on the tau neutrino-sterile neutrino mixing :math:`|U_{\tau N}|^2` as a function of the sterile neutrino mass :math:`m_N`. - :download:`All Data ` - :download:`PDF File `/:download:`PNG File ` - :download:`Plotting Code ` +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Experiment/Analysis | Reference | Data | +===============================================================================+==========================================================================+===========================================================================================================================================================================+ | IceCUBE + DeepCore | :cite:`TheIceCube:2016oqi,Aartsen:2017bap` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | SuperKamiokande (Oscillations) | :cite:`Abe:2014gda` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | T2K (Oscillations) | :cite:`Abe:2014gda` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | NOvA | :cite:`Adamson:2017zcg` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CHARM | :cite:`Orloff:2002de,Boiarska:2021yho` | :download:`.csv `, :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | BEBC | :cite:`Barouki:2022bkt` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | NOMAD | :cite:`Astier:2001ck` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Lepton Universality | :cite:`Cvetic:2017gkt` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | T2K (Decays) | :cite:`Abe:2019kgx` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | SuperKamiokande (Decays) | :cite:`Abe:2014gda` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | :math:`B` Decays | :cite:`Cvetic:2017gkt` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | L3 | :cite:`Adriani:1992pq` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | DELPHI | :cite:`Abreu:1996pa` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Electroweak Precision Data | :cite:`Blennow:2016jkn,deBlas:2013gla,delAguila:2008pw,Antusch:2014woa` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CMB :math:`\Delta N_{\mathrm{eff}}` | :cite:`Bridle:2016isd,Vincent:2014rja` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CMB + BAO + :math:`H_0` (or :math:`H_0` Only) | :cite:`Vincent:2014rja` | :download:`.csv ` (:download:`.csv `) | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Sterile Decays before BBN | :cite:`Boyarsky:2009ix,Ruchayskiy:2012si` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | NuSTAR X-rays | :cite:`Ng:2019gch,Roach:2019ctw` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Supernovae MSW Effect (Kopp) | :cite:`Arguelles:2016uwb` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Supernovae MSW Effect (Mirizzi) | :cite:`Mastrototaro:2019vug` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ Future Sensitivities ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ .. figure:: plots/UtauNsq_future.png :align: right :figwidth: 700px Future constraints on the tau neutrino-sterile neutrino mixing :math:`|U_{\tau N}|^2` as a function of the sterile neutrino mass :math:`m_N`. - :download:`All Data ` - :download:`PDF File `/:download:`PNG File ` - :download:`Plotting Code ` +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Experiment/Analysis | Reference | Data | +===============================================================================+========================================================+===============================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================+ | Current LNC Constraints (Blue Shaded) | :cite:`Bolton:2019pcu` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | DUNE | :cite:`Krasnov:2019kdc,Ballett:2019bgd` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | NA62 | :cite:`Drewes:2018gkc` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | FASER-2 | :cite:`Feng:2017uoz` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | SHiP | :cite:`SHiP:2018xqw` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | MATHUSLA | :cite:`Chou:2016lxi` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CODEX-b | :cite:`Aielli:2019ivi` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | B Factory | :cite:`Kobach:2014hea` | :download:`.csv `, :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Future LNV Meson Decays | :cite:`Chun:2019nwi` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | LHCb Displaced Vertex | :cite:`Antusch:2017hhu,Drewes:2019fou` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | ATLAS Displaced Vertex | :cite:`Drewes:2019fou` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CMS Displaced Vertex | :cite:`Drewes:2019fou` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | FCC-ee | :cite:`Blondel:2014bra` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | High Luminosity LHC (and FCC-hh) | :cite:`Pascoli:2018heg,Cheung:2020buy` | :download:`.csv `, :download:`.csv ` (:download:`.csv `) | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | ATHENA X-rays | :cite:`Neronov:2015kca` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | eROSITA X-rays | :cite:`Dekker:2021bos` | :download:`.csv ` | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+